Did Brian Leave Acdc

On April 16th, 1980, Brian Johnson became officially the frontman of AC/DC and a rock icon in the eyes of many fans. He took over the demanding vocal duties from Bon Scott after his unfortunate death and the band’s future seemed bright. But 36 years later, Brian Johnson abruptly announced in an official online statement that he was leaving AC/DC.

The shock news sent a wave of sadness among the fans, who also wondered what the real reasons for his sudden departure were. Was it related to the band’s health issues? Was it a decision based on personal reasons? So far, these questions remain unanswered. Many have speculated that the ongoing hearing problems Johnson was dealing with since the late ‘90s had something to do with it, arguing that the iconic vocalist was forced to leave AC/DC due to his worsening hearing.

Doctor of Audiology Stuart Segel, specializes in treatments related to hearing loss, has lent some insight into the potential reason why Johnson might have to leave the band. According to Segel, “Loud sounds, such as those created by rock bands, can cause damage/problems inside the ear. If Brian Johnson was playing with AC/DC for a long period of time with inadequate protection, it’s possible that his hearing would have been affected”. Segel also explains that unfortunately, at the moment, there is no way to know if Johnson’s hearing problems were indeed caused by AC/DC’s intense live shows, even though “it’s highly likely that any period of extremely loud audio exposure can cause some level of damage”.

To make matters worse, it appears as if AC/DC showed a lack of compassion and understanding towards Johnson’s situation, releasing an official statement as soon as they confirmed his departure. It was also reported that the band was searching for a temporary replacement as early as mid 2015, indicating that the decision to let Johnson go was taken well before his official departure.

The abrupt and almost callous manner in which Brian Johnson’s exit was handled has caused frustration and sadness among many fans. His vocal presence is sure to be missed, and AC/DC’s legacy looks to have suffered a huge blow. Rock legends aren’t replaceable and a new frontman may lead to a completely different approach and sound.

The effects on AC/DC’s Sound

The fact that AC/DC have now replaced Brian Johnson with a new singer raises serious questions about the band’s sound. Since Johnson has been in the band for so long and shaped their sound to a great extent, there’s no doubt that the musical content of their performances will eventually change. But just how much of a difference will the new voice make?

Most experts agree that it’s a risky business for AC/DC. “The problem with AC/DC’s new frontman is that Brian Johnson was so integral to the band’s sound,” says music expert Tom Smith. “He provided a unique vocal quality with a certain hard-edged quality. The question is how will the new frontman manage to keep that same sound without sounding like a carbon copy? As a fan, I’m not sure if I’m ready for that kind of change yet”.

Another issue Smith mentioned is the fact that fans may not take too kindly to the new singer, even if the band’s music sound is similar to what they’ve produced in the past. Loyal AC/DC fans may stay away from the band’s live shows, as the sight of a different frontman may not be met with welcoming arms.

AC/DC’s Future Potential

It’s difficult to predict what the future holds for AC/DC. The presence of a new singer and different sound quality may have an impact on fans’ level of enthusiasm towards the band. But it may also inspire fresh ideas and limitless potential for the group, who could gain a wider audience and build on the legacy left by its previous frontman, Brian Johnson.

Music producer and engineer Josh Smith has this to say about the band’s future potential: “AC/DC have a strong foundation that gained them immense popularity all over the world. It’s possible that the band will still do well even with a new singer, as long as they create great music and revamp their sound. That’s where I think lies the potential success of the group.” Smith added, “After all, what made AC/DC great was their powerhouse of anthems and range of sounds that always had that definitively rebel rock edge.”

However, a new vocalist is bound to come with new ambitions and different tastes in style and musical choice. “It’s up to the band to make sure the new singer’s talents are used without compromising the sound and character of AC/DC”, Smith claims. “If done correctly, the band could have a bright future ahead of them.”

The Adequacy of Live Replacements

In the wake of Brian Johnson’s departure, the band have come to a decision to bring in a replacement to take over the singer role during their live shows. Axl Rose, who is famously known as the lead singer of Guns N’ Roses, was first confirmed as the performer. But recently, Guns N’ Roses have extended their Not In This Lifetime tour, forcing Rose to back out due to double commitments.

Music journalist and reviewer Mark Noon shared his thoughts on this matter. According to Noon, “Bringing in Axl Rose as the front man of the band’s upcoming shows has definitely raised some eyebrows. He’s known for his unique style of rock music and he obviously does not fit the AC/DC mold. To have him singing classic AC/DC songs is going to be highly contentious for a lot of people.”

Noon also added that besides Rose, many other notable singers such as Axwell van Helden, have been similar to replace Brian Johnson temporarily. But it’s up to the members of AC/DC to find the right vocalist who can embrace the essence of the band and manage to retain and nurture its legacy.

Opposition to AC/DC’s New Singer

The news of the group’s decision to bring in a new frontman has been met with a great deal of criticism from many fans. While some have been more open-minded about the new addition to AC/DC, others remain doubtful, or even averse to the idea of a different singer taking the place of a beloved rock icon.

In claims Peter Starks, an AC/DC fan since the early ‘90s, “I’ve been with the band from the beginning. The idea of a new person taking over the vocal gig just doesn’t sit well with me. I don’t know what this will mean to the sound of the band, but it doesn’t feel right to replace Johnson.”

The passionate fan added, “I will remain loyal until the very end, but Brian Johnson should still be the one standing on that stage. His voice was a huge part of what AC/DC were about. I won’t be able to accept a new singer no matter what happens.”

The Debate on the Legacy of AC/DC

Brian Johnson was the face of AC/DC for many years, and his transfiguration of Bon Scott’s unique style made him one of the most applauded rock singers of all time. Now, with a new frontman to fill his shoes, new questions have emerged about the band’s sound and their overall legacy.

Leading rock critic Roger Wells has weighed in on this debate: “What will a new lead singer bring to the table when it comes to AC/DC’s legacy? That’s what’s everyone’s asking and it remains to be seen. The good news is, we know that AC/DC is very capable of making great music, which may help them adapt to the new changes and still resonate with their core audience. It’s not going to be a walk in the park, but it can still be a success.”


Edgar Grizzle

Edgar D. Grizzle is a passionate writer and music lover with a deep understanding of the rock and metal genres. A lifelong fan of classic and modern bands alike, he has honed his craft in writing about the music he loves over the past decade. He is committed to giving readers an accurate and captivating look into the music that he loves, and he is dedicated to helping fans discover new music and explore the rich history of rock and metal.

Leave a Comment